Wednesday, April 06, 2005

Do people really mean it when they say they just want what's best for everyone?

7 comments:

John said...

No.

The giveaway is the word 'just.' If they say they 'just' want anything, they're selling something. Usually it means they are (a) willing to be the arbiter of what is best for everyone, and (b) willing to apportion whatever compromise will be required to approach that mean. Usually by assigning it to you, with the next phrase: "Be reasonable."

On the other hand, who has ever heard the phrase without the 'just'? "I want what's best for everyone." Sounds a bit grandiose. Sounds impossible. Sounds obvious. The 'just' tones it down. If you 'just' want that, your motives are good! You're a good person.

On the other, other hand, who has ever heard, "I just want what's best for Nicole -- I really don't care what happens to Ashley"? Or: "I just want what's best for the team -- I really don't care what happens to me."

We have heard this of course. And it's quite refreshing. Now we're getting somewhere. We have an idea where you stand. That you do have a stand.

Where everything is given an equal gloss of impossibly easy goodness, it's harder to find truth.

Then again, maybe I misunderstood the question. :-)

Emly said...

Um, no. You already knew that.

Emly said...

HOW DARE YOU DELETE MY COMMENT

Unknown said...

I saved the link and then deleted the post, silly girl. What, this is your private/public messaging forum? Sheesh.

Unknown said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Emly said...

oh I see.

Emly said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.